Posted: Mar 20, 2012 7:13 am Post subject: uh oh...it's going to be the wild, wild west...
Quote:
OKLAHOMA CITY - A Senate panel approved a measure Thursday that would allow for the open carrying of firearms.
Senate Bill 1733 by Sen. Anthony Sykes, R-Moore, passed the Senate Public Safety Committee by a vote of 8-1.
Sen. Constance Johnson, D-Oklahoma City, cast the lone vote against it. She could not be reached for comment after the meeting.
The measure heads to the Senate floor.
Sykes said the measure passed a few years ago and was vetoed by former Gov. Brad Henry.
"It is basically open carry in Oklahoma except this version of open carry you have to have your concealed-carry license, and it is your choice. You can carry concealed. You can carry unconcealed," he said.
The measure has a provision that allows judges to carry as long as they go through the training and put their names on a list with the administrative director of the courts, Sykes said.
House Speaker Kris Steele, R-Shawnee, said he supports open carry with reasonable restrictions, such as background checks and training.
"Gov. Fallin has not reviewed this measure yet nor is she ready to offer a commitment this early in the legislative process," said Alex Weintz, a Fallin spokesman. "She is, however, a strong supporter of Second Amendment rights and has said she favors the principles behind 'open carry' legislation."
The Tulsa Metro Chamber has not taken a position on the legislation, said LToya Knighten, a chamber spokeswoman.
Nathan Atkins, a spokesman for Senate Pro Tem Brian Bingman, R-Sapulpa, said the senator supports the bill.
Bingman believes the measure is a responsible pro-Second Amendment bill that includes safeguards found in the current concealed carry laws, Atkins said.
"Though this bill is still working its way through the process, the pro tem is optimistic fellow legislators will support an open-carry bill that includes thoughtful provisions such as background checks and firearms training," Atkins said.
Nice! _________________ There'll be two dates on your tombstone/ And all your friends will read 'em/ But all that's gonna matter is that little dash between 'em...
The whole thing seems like a stupid waste of time to me.
I don't live there, so I don't really care what people on Oklohama do.
I am interested in seeing what happens, though. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
Okie Boarder, I certainly don't think it will be the wild west, but especially in light of what just happened in FL, I'd be calling the cops, a LOT if I lived in OK.
Personally, I think if people want to do this they should have their license on display as well. Like a damn fishing license. Clip it to your hat, shirt, something. At least have something to ID yourself as a legal carrier.
Otherwise, you are just some random nutjob with a gun to me. And I'll be dialing 9-1-1 right now TYVM.
Guns have a time and place. On your hip when you walk in to the grocery store is neither the time nor the place. _________________
I would not want to be a cop there. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
Guns have a time and place. On your hip when you walk in to the grocery store is neither the time nor the place.
Agree and disagree
If you’re in the store and you are carrying, make it not be seen. Guns scare people, and rightfully so, because people themselves are crazy. How do we know you or I aren’t crazy? Get my point...because we sure think other are! Plus sometimes it’s like a magnet, it draws bad people towards you if they have bad intentions.
On the disagree side, if stuff hits the fan, you have control of your own life if it does... even if your killed.
I carry every day, but no one knows because it’s concealed. I was attacked by an individual and if it weren't for martial arts training (2nd degree) he may have got the upper hand. I'm not saying that a gun would have taken care of the problem, because it may have made it worse, but he wouldn't have got the chance to get closer to me with the knife he was holding. With a concealed weapons permit, its your civic duty to protect others as well, so it serve a purpose I believe. Granted the local DA may spin it on you, but it’s a chance when you carry.
For me it bowls down to this; you have the right to carry, and our forefathers gave us that right. No laws or congressman should be able to pass or make a law that would void this agreement.
If you know I’m carrying, and I know you’re carrying, we will both know to leave each other alone.
I’ll be the first to tell someone openly, in a public forum, you mess with my family and you are gambling losing your life. I refuse to let the government determine the outcome of such… Therefore I carry.
I'm not against concealed carry, in and of itself, but I don't think that the 2and amendment gives us that right.
Why is there never a gun discussion without someone feeling it necessary to say this:
Quote:
you mess with my family and you are gambling losing your life.
and it's always someone who's a carry advocate, usually someone who's been a victim as well? _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
I'm not against concealed carry, in and of itself, but I don't think that the 2and amendment gives us that right.
You are correct, it doesn’t, because you are allowed to carry openly by this law.
Why is there never a gun discussion without someone feeling it necessary to say this:
Quote:
you mess with my family and you are gambling losing your life.
Because it gets the point across, and lot of people have never been put in a position to have their life endangered
and it's always someone who's a carry advocate, usually someone who's been a victim as well?
Maybe so, and I probably should have worded it more properly. I do not carry every where. I go to the store and such without, and honestly, I go a lot of places without it on my side, but it’s with me in the car or motorcycle. I carry when in very 'diverse' place, or when traveling.
[/b]
I think it's more a fundamental part of the psychological makeup of SOME people that feel the need to carry a gun in public.
Why do you go to the store without carrying your gun?
Do you think that leaving it in a car or on your motorcycle (Locked hard saddlebag, I'm assuming?) is reason for any concern? Are you afraid it will get stolen? Or that you will walk up on someone inside your car, and attempt to stop them, to have them shoot you with your own gun? _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
Of course the "wild, wild west" statement was tongue-in-cheek. I will say that I have been in an area that is open carry and my in-laws live there. They don't have problems with it. I haven't looked at the statistics, but from the impression I get from them, it certainly isn't causing a problem. _________________ If love is blind, why is lingerie so popular?
I agree, I think it's more a fundamental part of the psychological makeup of some people that feel the need to carry a gun in public. I give you that. As for me, I’m not sure to be honest.
Maybe it’s because I've had someone approach the car, twice, with knifes in a bad part of town we were working and I did not see them. Maybe it makes me feel better knowing if they were to try again, I'd be able to react. Granted leaving it in the vehicle while I’m out of it makes no sense at all, but we all get conformable being places and not worrying about what happens. More to the point and maybe a little more information about travel habit would be useful for my situation, not everyone else’s, as mine are very limited to an area now, instead of how they were in the past. We used this as an example, not a means to attack someone of their habits or thoughts on whether to carry or not. The simple part of being able to carry is at your will. I’m simply implying it shouldn’t be an issue that is controlled by our government for all places not funded by the government or group event (IE: Football game).
Grocery store to me just seems like a place to be humble, which is an illusion I know, but I don’t believe my grocery stores been held up by a person / group with intentions of holding anyone hostage. Maybe I'd carry in other grocery stores… or if I visited Detroit.
Maybe i would carry if I was in an area where I was likely to be attacked, IDK. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
I think it's more a fundamental part of the psychological makeup of SOME people that feel the need to carry a gun in public.
^this^
You could probably write a PhD dissertation on people who feel the desire to carry in public, and their underlying psychological issues making them wish to do so.
Personally, I think it's some sort of deep seated insecurity issue. Either that, or some delusion of grandeur. IDK. What I do know is that in modern society, at least in the USA (and so many other modern countries) it is in no way necessary, and likely will cause more harm than good. _________________
i have a shotgun on the backglass of my truck, shells in glovebox and a Cobia bat mounted in the cab next to my seat. best to be preppared for the worst then to be completely unprepared. im with BrianABE, it is all physcological _________________ Lanexa VA
I would not be surprised to learn that NY has a law against leaving a firearm in your vehicle in plain view.
All you who go around with a bat next to your seat and a gun in your glove box should sell your 80K wakeboarding boats and move to a safer neighborhood.
that's sort of a joke, I know you sometimes have to travel or work in bad areas... _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
Firearms are just tools. They can be used with good intentions or bad, just like any other tool\device. Not everyone should be allowed to carry a gun. However, those who you WANT carrying guns are those who respect the laws enough not to (in forbidden states). Carry laws only inhibit THOSE people. They do not inhibit the criminals who carry them around you every day.
Gun paranoid people always say that those who own\carry guns are influenced by movies and are all wanna be heros. I would say that the gun paranoid are far more influenced by the movies\media. They believe guns are these nafarious items that do evil. They aparently arent scared of criminals with guns because hey, they always miss, right? They are simply a hole punch with no power to fill a man with bloodlust. If these people would actually go shoot one and remove the mystique, gun laws would be a non-issue.
On a side note, they are voting in TX this month to allow use of our supressors while hunting game animals (we can already hunt non-game with them.) Will be really nice for those who do not like their ears ringing for a week after taking a shot at a deer, as well as those living near hunting leases. _________________ TONA
I grew up with guns. I've visited my share of ranges, put rounds through a wide variety of guns. I have no problem with guns. I do not currently own any guns at the request of SWMBO. I am fine with that. I no longer hunt, so I have zero need for a firearm of any kind anyway.
Where I have a big problem is when those guns are introduced into situations they do not belong in.
I don't know the person carrying the gun. He/she isn't clearly a peace officer, or a security guard, they are just some random person with a weapon that can inflict lethal force from a great distance. I don't want that person anywhere around me, or my family, and I WILL exercise MY RIGHT to call 9-1-1 and let them sort it out. The process to obtain a CCW permit isn't exactly onerous from what I have found here in the "liberal" state of CA. Certainly won't prevent some guy with a Rambo complex from getting one. Nor would it prevent someone from lying their ass off during the live interview. So the point is, IDK that person, and AFAIK they have not gone through many months of peace office training, nor is that person acting in the normal course of their business from what I can observe.
So I ask myself, WTF is that person doing with a gun at the supermarket? Obviously, there is NO good answer, so the phone will come out and 9-1-1 will be dialed. And my family and I will be leaving, post-haste.
I have no problem with suppressors. Especially on hunting rifles. I'm not at all concerned with hunters who are legally exercising their right to hunt so long as they are in compliance with the law. _________________
IMO the same could be said about driving on the highway. You dont know the guy next to you and he could make an attempt on your life without warning in a blink of an eye.
For me it would be more about the mannerisms of the person than what he had on him. A guy comes in mad and stressed, 9-1-1 is getting called whether its a gun, a bat, a tire iron, or a knife in his hand. Now if a guy comes in with his tire iron and is a calm normal looking guy and he walks straight to automotive, I wouldnt give it a second look. If YOU walked into a supermarket in your khakis on your way home from work and you had a pistol holstered on your belt I wouldnt give it a second look. Some meth head comes in all nervous with a pistol tucked into the waist of his cut-off jorts, I dial the phone. Same with the highway, I dont care what he is driving, I care how he is driving. Driving bad, I dont care if its a motorcycle, im calling someone. if he drives well, he could be driving truck-a-saurus for all I care.
You simply cant write laws in an attempt to control those who dont abide by laws. Those who come into the market armed and are up to no good are going to do so regardless of the law. The best thing a community can do to limit the damage of these people is allow those who are upright to defend themselves instantly. _________________ TONA
The process to obtain a CCW permit isn't exactly onerous from what I have found here in the "liberal" state of CA. Certainly won't prevent some guy with a Rambo complex from getting one. Nor would it prevent someone from lying their ass off during the live interview.
You've got to be joking me... In Sacramento County you interview with a detective, who submits a report for review by 3 command level Sheriffs, then you have to be cleared by livescan and the DOJ. After that you must complete 16 hours of training and range qualification course.
They weed things out here and I think you're being a bit dramatic with that verbage. _________________ If I agreed with you we would both be wrong.
Now wait, you brought in the idea of risk. I dont think risk cares about the device inventors intended purpose. Its like your saying vehicular homicide\manslaughter is not a concern since the inventor of the automobile didnt have that in mind when he introduced it to the world. Just like the majority of car owners arent out killing people with their cars, CHL owners arent out killing people with their guns. One should view everyone with a gun as you do everyone on the road. Everyone capable of causing death, but comfortable because 99.9% do not.
People should carry a gun as they do a spare tire. _________________ TONA
I would not be surprised to learn that NY has a law against leaving a firearm in your vehicle in plain view.
Haha only like 3 years ago my highschool made it against the rules to leave your shotgun/rifle in your truck in plain sight. Under the seats or locked in toolbox and your fine _________________ Lanexa VA
For me it would be more about the mannerisms of the person than what he had on him.
JasonSSR believes he can tell the bad guys by how they look and act before they try to hurt someone or commit a crime.
Is that from watching too many movies?
Quote:
Firearms are just tools. They can be used with good intentions or bad, just like any other tool\device.
Except that a handgun is a tool that is specifically designed to kill other people. (Most of them, anyway).
The comparison between a gun and a vehicle is silly at best.
Quote:
Those who come into the market armed and are up to no good are going to do so regardless of the law.
So then, is it your ridiculous assertion, that people with the best of intentions don't get angry, or get into altercations over things like parking spots, the last item on a shelf, a perceived insult, etc. etc?
Because I think that GOOD people sometimes lose their tempers. Sometimes two good people get into an altercation, sometimes it gets physical.
I don't have any data that supports any conclusion as to what happens when people lose their tempers and get into fights AND happen to be carrying handguns, but I have a suspicion that it might not turn out as well as if they only had, say... their fists.
Not to say that MOST people aren't in control of themselves, but I think we can all agree that having a gun can often change SOME people's usual reactions to conflict. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
I would not be surprised to learn that NY has a law against leaving a firearm in your vehicle in plain view.
Haha only like 3 years ago my highschool made it against the rules to leave your shotgun/rifle in your truck in plain sight. Under the seats or locked in toolbox and your fine
Really? Here in GA you aren't even allowed to be in a school zone with a gun in the car, even if you just passing by the school on the main road. Sure, they don't have a road block checking people, but the law just reads this way. If you were caught with a shotgun or something in your vehicle, you did not pass go... You went to jail, and this was back in the late 80's early 90's.
I know there is a lot of negative remarks in this post, but some good does come out of people carrying guns...
Insert this; happend around my local lake
By MIKE MORRIS
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Published on: 09/12/05
An apparent carjacking victim was killed Monday morning in north Cobb County when her sport utility vehicle was broadsided by a cement truck. The suspected carjacker was then shot to death by a bystander when he tried to run from the wreck scene.
About 9:30 a.m., a motorist northbound on Cobb Parkway noticed a white Toyota SUV pulled over to the side of the southbound lanes just south of the Lake Allatoona bridge, said Cobb police Cpl. Dana Pierce.
A man was beating a woman outside the SUV, and the northbound motorist stopped his vehicle and started across the four-lane roadway to help the woman, said Pierce.
The suspect then pushed the woman back into the SUV and took off, with the doors to the SUV still open. A short distance later, the suspect tried to turn left onto Lake Acworth Drive, and a northbound cement mixer struck the SUV in the passenger's side, killing the woman, Pierce said.
Pierce said the suspect exited the SUV and was running toward a nearby gas station when he was shot and killed in the middle of the roadway by a man who had gotten out of a southbound Dodge pickup truck.
Acworth police spokesman Wayne Dennard said his department is investigating the possibility that the man killed Monday morning was the suspect in a Tuesday rape allegedly committed by a Hurricane Katrina evacuee.
"He does meet the general description," Dennard said.
Dennard said the victim of Tuesday's rape told investigators that her attacker "said he was from Louisiana and his family was dead and he had nothing to lose."
While it might be good that this person won't be able to harm anyone else, I prefer my laws to be enforced by the people trained and appointed to enforce them.
I'm not comfortable with someone shooting across a street at someone running away, especially someone who isn't specifically trained to think and react in those situations.
You could say "what if that was your wife or girlfriend that he was going to abduct next" and you would have a point.
But I also say "what if it was your kid walking to school who was accidentally shot because some guy shot a fleeing suspect?"
Or what if people decide that it's ok to shoot a person who appears to be fleeing the scene of a crime, and maybe a second victim gets shot by accident while running from their attacker, mistaken for the attacker?
idk.... You could collect these stories from Guns N Ammo magazine and use them to support a position, but I think they are far from representative of the general reality. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
cameraboy, your hypothetic scenarios can and have happened with trained peace officers, as well. So, what makes you feel better about them being the only ones carrying the guns and acting in the manner you're describing? _________________ If love is blind, why is lingerie so popular?
The process to obtain a CCW permit isn't exactly onerous from what I have found here in the "liberal" state of CA. Certainly won't prevent some guy with a Rambo complex from getting one. Nor would it prevent someone from lying their ass off during the live interview.
You've got to be joking me... In Sacramento County you interview with a detective, who submits a report for review by 3 command level Sheriffs, then you have to be cleared by livescan and the DOJ. After that you must complete 16 hours of training and range qualification course.
They weed things out here and I think you're being a bit dramatic with that verbage.
Sixte...errr... EIGHT hours of something you like to do? No wai. Talking the talk to a detec... err... "Member of the Sherriff's support staff"? Nobody does that, ever.
They don't weed out sh*t. They put on a front like they do. The whole process is a joke - and this is liberal land of CA.
Okie - P.O.S.T. <<nuff said. Peace officers have a difficult and lengthy process they go through to become officers. That is why we are able to trust them with handguns. _________________
JasonSSR believes he can tell the bad guys by how they look and act before they try to hurt someone or commit a crime.
Is that from watching too many movies?
No, its common sense. Are you telling me that with all your years living in the world, that you cannot spot a trouble maker? You have never been in a bar and saw someone you knew was looking for a fight? Most people with any experience in public and have half a brain can recognize trouble when they see it. You seem like a smart guy so I have a feeling you know exactly what Im talking about and are acting naive for the purpose of debate.
Quote:
Except that a handgun is a tool that is specifically designed to kill other people. (Most of them, anyway).
The comparison between a gun and a vehicle is silly at best.
Its is designed to poke a hole in whatever needs a hole. It has far more noble applications than criminal ones. The comparison to cars was on the assessment of risk. Getting on a road full of DL holders is far more risky than walking into a gorcery full of CHL holders. Even though you are more likely to die from a vehicle than from being shot period, much less from a CHL holder, you are more comfortable on the road simply because of the inventors intention? Sounds like gun paranoia to me.
Quote:
So then, is it your ridiculous assertion, that people with the best of intentions don't get angry, or get into altercations over things like parking spots, the last item on a shelf, a perceived insult, etc. etc?
Because I think that GOOD people sometimes lose their tempers. Sometimes two good people get into an altercation, sometimes it gets physical.
Good people lose their tempers all the time. That does not equate to shootings. If anything, those who carry are much more likely to avoid conflict BECAUSE they carry. People tend to allow things to escalate when the outcome is uncertain. However, when a CHL holder is carrying, the potential outcome is well known and that reality trumps any emotional escalation.
Quote:
I don't have any data that supports any conclusion as to what happens when people lose their tempers and get into fights AND happen to be carrying handguns...
Its because there is no negative data to draw the conclusion your looking for. The people who actually understand the responsibility enough to take the time to get a CHL arent your hot head troublemakers.
Quote:
Not to say that MOST people aren't in control of themselves, but I think we can all agree that having a gun can often change SOME people's usual reactions to conflict.
Yes, but not in they way you would expect based on reruns of SVU. _________________ TONA
cameraboy, your hypothetic scenarios can and have happened with trained peace officers, as well. So, what makes you feel better about them being the only ones carrying the guns and acting in the manner you're describing?
I believe that they are LESS likely to happen when trained peace officers are the ones chasing and shooting at suspects.
Quote:
No, its common sense. Are you telling me that with all your years living in the world, that you cannot spot a trouble maker? You have never been in a bar and saw someone you knew was looking for a fight? Most people with any experience in public and have half a brain can recognize trouble when they see it. You seem like a smart guy so I have a feeling you know exactly what Im talking about and are acting naive for the purpose of debate.
If people intending to do you harm always acted weird and in an obvious manner, nobody would ever be victimized.
It's folly to believe that people with bad intentions ALWAYS give themselves away with their behavior before trying to hurt someone.
It's only in the movies where every "bad guy" wears black and has a scar or maybe a british accent.
Quote:
Even though you are more likely to die from a vehicle than from being shot period, much less from a CHL holder, you are more comfortable on the road simply because of the inventors intention?
I encounter perhaps several hundred to a thousand cars on the road every day, in parking lots, in my neighbor's driveways, etc.
I'm not overly concerned because driving is an accepted risk I have to take in order to maintain my role in this society. Cars are not designed to kill people, that is an unfortunate result, sometimes, of their frequent use.
Handguns, with a few notable exceptions, are designed to kill other people.
Their comparison to a car is completely unwarranted, even in terms of risk.
You are barking up the wrong tree with the "gun paranoia" comment. I'll wager I've put more rounds downrange and also into living things than you have. I've been shooting shotguns, rifles, and pistols since I was in single digits. I have no fear of guns themselves. I DO have a fear of people who carry guns through their daily lives. Because SOME PEOPLE are unpredictable, irrational, and often emotional. And when you add a gun into that mix.... what could POSSIBLY go wrong?
Quote:
The people who actually understand the responsibility enough to take the time to get a CHL arent your hot head troublemakers.
George Zimmerman legally carried his handgun on Feb 26th. Whether he shot Trayvon Martin in self defense or not is something that will have to be sorted out in court, but the 911 tapes make it pretty clear that Zimmerman was following the boy. Would he have followed the boy, and thus provoked some sort of confrontation (which he alludes that he is seeking on the 911 tapes) if he was not legally carrying his handgun?
Does being armed change people's behavior? I think that sometimes, it does.
SHOOT. Chavez beat me to it... _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
chavez, elect a different Sheriff then. I met with both candidates in my county and spoke to them on this issue specifically. You also live in a more affluent area with lower crime and more rural areas. I can see why it would be easier. It's not that easy from those I know with CCWs but that's in my county where permit applications are already closed for the year and you have to interview with a detective who while you're skeptical are trained to see through BS. _________________ If I agreed with you we would both be wrong.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum