An air traffic controller and his supervisor are under investigation because the controller allegedly brought his two small children into the control tower and allowed them to speak with pilots on an air traffic control frequency.
i gotta be honest with you, I don't think this is that awful. I heard some of the audio, and the kids are supervised, it's not like they are deciding what to say...
idk... people are REALLY upset about this, but for some reason, I just don't seem to think it was that horrible. _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
There are certain jobs that bringing your kids is no big deal. This doesn't seem like one of them to me. There was some special on a few nights ago that showed what the AT Controllers went through the morning of 9/11. I can't imaging the chaos it would have been & having small children in there.
It's probably more of a "what if" danger than anything. _________________ http://www.youtube.com/greasemonkeytv
Joined: 14 Jan 2003 Posts: 5088 City: New Hampshire
Posted: Mar 04, 2010 6:23 am Post subject:
I don't see anything wrong with that either.
Sounds like everyone knew what was going on, the pilots would have questioned anything they didn't understand.
What ever happened to take your child to work day?
Wasn't the whole point of that program to teach kids what the real world was all about.
The Kid probably felt very important when his dad let him do that and in turn made his dad proud and happy Jr. did such a good job.
I guess Jr. did learn what the real world is all about - he learned it's full of a bunch of hypercritic people who have nothing better to do with their time than to worry about chit that means nothing in the grand scheme of things. They are reacting like he locked himself in the room and was running the show all by himself..
The only thing I question is how did people even find out about this? _________________ PEACE
Aubs wrote:
J Dogg - I thought of you last night.
"Everyone wants a bite, it don't happen over night"!
cameraboy, J_DOGG, i have to disagree. putting your kid in a seat that assumes responsibilty of the lives of several others is idiotic. While they were supervised, what happens if an emergency breaks out. When you have an issue in plane every second counts and I sure as hell wouldn't want some kid on the other end of the mic. _________________
RampageWake wrote:
Wakeboardrumma wrote:
have good clean honest fun without alcohol.
After you do that, help me find me leprechaun.....
This is why I hate the f*cking media. They make this seem like the kid was going to cause a crash but the controllers were standing right behind the kid telling him exactly what to say. I recognize the voice of the guy saying something like "This is what you get when the kids are out of school" or whatever and he's a veteran controller and I hear his voice in a ton of clips on liveatc.net and he's a pro. We talked about this in the ATC class I'm taking this semester and my instructor, a retired controller, said the kid did nothing wrong and had perfect phraseology. The FAA is making a big deal about it because they don't want to look bad that a kid was directing traffic. If it was at a small airport it wouldn't be such a big deal and I understand that JFK is an extremely busy airport, but the kid knew what to say, when to say it, and the pilots didn't give a damn. Props to that kid for not panicking that he was on the frequency but a big one finger salute to the FAA, ATCA, and the media.
Lop, the controller came on the frequency after the kids initial radio call so he was listening in and able to transmit on his own mic, so an emergency would've been handled immediately and the kid would've been asked to step out of the area.
And probably with another ATC standing behind the dad. Now I'm not in any flight classes but from what I've been told by pilots, there are multiple safety layers up there watching what is going on. _________________
dizzlestoy wrote:
Dumb question... What is "Bubb Rubbing" I googled it and wakeboarder.com came up.
Not a big deal at all, I hear plenty of pilots letting their kids make transmission from the other end. If the kid gets it wrong they are right there to straighten it out. There are pilots flying around in this area who barely speak english at all. The controllers have to give them instructions multiple times, and I'm usually not sure that they understand. Those are the people that worry me when I'm in the air, not the kid who has been around it all their life.
That said I'm sure this was against the rules and the controller should have known better. But he deserves nothing more than a slap on the wrist for it.
someone replied to a hater with this: "you're not in control. no matter what you do .. a child could say it's clear or a PARROT could say it's clear, either way you're going somewhere."
have any of you actually heard the audio, then listened to when JFK is actually busy....HUGE difference. They kid was perfect! I head this on liveatc as well way before this hit the media.
holdsworth, i second your finger. _________________ Whenever I see an $80,000 Wakesetter pulling a tuber, I die a little inside.
Joined: 25 Aug 2003 Posts: 5283 City: New York City
Posted: Mar 04, 2010 8:53 am Post subject:
I agree that this is ridiculous. The kid was supervised and there was no danger. If something had gone wrong, the guy whose job it is, IS RIGHT THERE. Its ridiculous how big of a deal they are making this when there was simply no harm or danger in what was done.
My $0.02. I have absolutely no problem with this whatsoever. This is being blown totally out of proportion, and I really hope this doesn't cost anyone their career.
Even one of the pilots said "good job" to the kid. Because he did, in fact, do a good job. _________________
my point is that they added a point of failure that was not necessary and when it is something that could possibly result in disaster and death it just didn't need to happen _________________
RampageWake wrote:
Wakeboardrumma wrote:
have good clean honest fun without alcohol.
After you do that, help me find me leprechaun.....
Joined: 25 Jul 2006 Posts: 2124 City: Some Airport
Posted: Mar 04, 2010 9:43 am Post subject:
I agree 100% that this shouldn't have been a big deal. At first, when I discovered it was JFK, I was a bit disconcerted, but it really doesn't sound like this occurred during a busy period or a crisis.
That experience SHOULD have been a very special one to the kid, given them something to brag to their class about, and maybe inspired a career in aviation. Instead, it results in this mess and has negatively impacted the adults involved. Without these sort of experiences, take your kid to work day loses much of its value. Obviously the activities should be well supervised and performed in a controlled environment, but I don't see anything about this that indicates it put anyone at significant risk.
Joined: 25 Aug 2003 Posts: 5283 City: New York City
Posted: Mar 04, 2010 10:55 am Post subject:
Quote:
when it is something that could possibly result in disaster and death it just didn't need to happen
please explain how it could possibly result in disaster and death...if the kid instructed two planes to collide, the dad would immediately radio a correction before the kid finished the sentence.
Later, an FAA official who asked not to be identified because of the ongoing investigation said the controller brought his daughter into the same tower the following day, and the child was allowed to talk with pilots of two planes.
...some comments about how (harmlessly) the conversation was...
The pilot chuckles and says, "Wish I could bring my kid to work." The same pilot later tells the child, "Awesome job."
This is pretty much the end of the story to me. There is absolutely no issue here whatsoever, and the fact that this is making news in any sort of serious manner is ridiculous. _________________ Keep Austin Weird
ok... so lets say that during this time the kid screwed up, two planes collided and 100 or so people died. This thread would be completely different and everybody would be all over teh ACTs ass. It didn't happen so everythign is ok? FAA rules should be ignored becasue nobody got hurt? _________________
RampageWake wrote:
Wakeboardrumma wrote:
have good clean honest fun without alcohol.
After you do that, help me find me leprechaun.....
Nothing the kid could have said would cause 2 planes to instantly collide. As long as the real ATCs weren't off drinking beers, not supervising the kid I don't see the harm. _________________
dizzlestoy wrote:
Dumb question... What is "Bubb Rubbing" I googled it and wakeboarder.com came up.
I heard this on the news this morning and wondered why it was even newsworthy. At most, the controller needs to be told not to let his kids talk on the radio because there's a risk the media try to make a story out of it. I wish news people could get fired for blowing stupid stuff out of proportion.
ok... so lets say that during this time the kid screwed up, two planes collided and 100 or so people died. This thread would be completely different and everybody would be all over teh ACTs ass. It didn't happen so everythign is ok? FAA rules should be ignored becasue nobody got hurt?
That wouldn't have happened because the father is supervising the kid. It's like letting your kid sit on your lap and steer the car the last 100yds to your house. In that situation the parent is still in control of the gas/brake. And will take the wheel if there is any need at all.
Nothing different could have happened because the kid gave a routine order. It could have been a computerized voice for all it mattered as long as the order is given at the proper time.
The pilot and ATC even had a goodnatured conversation about it. No issue. _________________ Keep Austin Weird
I wish news people could get fired for blowing stupid stuff out of proportion.
I would love to turn on the news, or the make pretend news (fox) and see/hear this: "Today, there's not really anything important going on, so enjoy this episode of The Simpsons!" _________________ I walk 47 miles of barb wire, I got a cobra snake for a necktie, a brand new house up on the road side, and it's made out of rattlesnake hide
In the end its the pilots decision that counts. You rarely hear of "ATC" error. If the pilot does not feel it is the safe or correct order/direction to follow, he/she doesn't have too. End of story.
The little kid was giving departure clearance, and to "contract departure", which is a hand-off to another controller most likely sitting next to the little kid!
The pilot had to be put into position first (on the runway), which means the controller has deemed the runway clear and safe, and the pilot has agreed. The IFR clearance/and release had already been givin and read back. The clearance and instructions that the little kid gave was equal to "welcome to mcdonalds".
And as stated before its not like the guy gave the kid a mic and head set and left! Most likely the kid was on dads lap and dad keyed up the mic and the kid spoke.
This is so blown out of proportion. _________________ Whenever I see an $80,000 Wakesetter pulling a tuber, I die a little inside.
Joined: 29 Aug 2003 Posts: 5291 City: hendersonville
Posted: Mar 05, 2010 1:38 pm Post subject:
Lop wrote:
ok... so lets say that during this time the kid screwed up, two planes collided and 100 or so people died. This thread would be completely different and everybody would be all over teh ACTs ass. It didn't happen so everythign is ok? FAA rules should be ignored becasue nobody got hurt?
I'm sorry but this quite an ignorant statement. The planes dont fly anywhere close enough to each other or make quick enough movements for them the be affected by the kids words with the ATCs on the line monitoring everything to make sure it's perfect. They're not fighter jets in an air show...
And 9/11 was a different story. I'm sure if it happened during that time the kids would have been escorted out to let the people do their jobs 110%.
This is definitely not a news worthy story IMO. _________________
eeven73 wrote:
At least 50% of the population is retarded so I discount what they think or feel automatically.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum